Midwest hail damage · John Beal Roofing since 1947
Hail Damage to Windows, Screens, Wraps and Trim
Most of the proof that a storm hit your address is standing at eye level where anybody can photograph it. Almost nobody does.
Short answer
The evidence that a hailstorm hit your house is usually at eye level, not on the roof. Window screens tear or dish inward on the elevation the storm came from. Aluminum wrap on window and door trim dents in a scatter you can read from ten feet away. Sills, garage doors, gable vents and exterior light fixtures take the same strikes. Because all of it can be photographed from the ground, it is the fastest way to establish that a storm produced damaging hail at your specific address, which is the thing a carrier questions first.
Screens tell you the direction
Hail almost never falls straight down in a Midwest storm. It comes in on the wind at an angle, so the damage concentrates on one or two elevations of the house. Screens show that better than anything else on the property. A stone that hits a screen either tears the mesh or pushes it into a shallow dish that never comes back out, and the frame corners can pop loose. Walk the house and count which sides have dished screens. That's your storm direction, and it should line up with the elevations where the shingle damage is heaviest. When the two don't match, something is off, and it's worth sorting out before anybody files.
Aluminum wrap and trim coil
Most homes built or re-trimmed in the last thirty years have aluminum coil wrapped over the wood trim at windows, doors and rakes. It's thin and flat, and it dents like a car hood. A hail scatter on wrap is one of the cleanest photographs that can go into a claim file, because the dents are unmistakable and they sit at a height where an adjuster doesn't need a ladder to see them. Look at the wrap in raking light, early morning or late afternoon, with your eye close to the plane of the surface. The dimples jump out. Midday sun flattens them and you'll swear the trim is fine.
Garage doors, gable vents and light fixtures
A steel garage door panel is a large soft-metal target sitting three feet off the driveway. Dents show on the flat sections between the ribs, and on an insulated door they can be shallow enough that you have to sight down the panel from one end to catch them. Vinyl and aluminum gable vents crack or dent. Exterior light fixtures crack at the glass and dent on the hoods. Mailboxes, downspout elbows, the dryer vent hood, patio furniture, the lid of the grill. None of it is worth much on its own, and together it becomes a pattern that no carrier can reasonably write off as age.
The two things people mean by wrap
Aluminum coil over exterior trim is the one that matters for a hail claim, and it's the one adjusters look at. Housewrap is different. The synthetic weather barrier behind the siding never gets struck directly, but it comes into play once siding is damaged badly enough to be removed, because code in most Midwest jurisdictions requires the barrier to be repaired or replaced when the wall is opened up. That's a legitimate line item and it's one of the most commonly omitted pieces of a siding scope. If your estimate has siding removal on it and no weather barrier, somebody left money on the table.
We look at the whole house, not just the roof
A hail inspection that stops at the gutter line is half an inspection. Our walk covers every elevation at ground level before anybody sets a ladder: screens, wraps, sills, doors, vents, fixtures, the condenser, the mailbox. It adds twenty minutes and it routinely changes the outcome of a claim, because it converts a roof opinion into a storm record. John Beal Roofing has been doing this across the Midwest since 1947, and the ground-level photographs are the ones we get asked for most often when a file goes to a second review.
Why non-roof damage helps the roof claim
Carriers are skeptical of roof-only claims and they have reason to be. A roof is hard to see, easy to misrepresent, and it's where the money is. Damage at eye level changes that conversation completely. If the north and west screens are dished, the west window wrap is dimpled, the garage door carries a scatter and the condenser fins are flattened on the same side, then hail of a damaging size came through this address out of the northwest. The roof damage stops being an assertion about a roof and becomes one part of a documented storm event. That's why we photograph the ground-level items even when the call that brought us out was only about shingles.
Matching, siding and the argument that follows
When siding or wrap is damaged and the product has been discontinued, which happens constantly with vinyl colors, you land in a matching dispute. Some Midwest states have matching regulations or department-of-insurance bulletins calling for a reasonably uniform appearance. Others leave the question entirely to the policy wording. The practical result is that two neighbors with identical damage and different carriers can get very different answers about whether one elevation gets replaced or all four do. We document the product, the color code stamped on the back of a panel where there is one, and the discontinuation, because that's the material that actually moves the conversation forward.
What to photograph before anyone shows up
Do it within a few days if you can, and do it before a contractor touches anything. Shoot each elevation of the house wide, then move in close on every dented item with something in frame for scale. Get the screens from inside and outside. Get the condenser from above so the flattened fins are visible. Leave your phone's timestamp alone and don't crop it out. If a neighbor already has a tarp up or a yard sign in the grass, a wide shot of the street is useful context for an adjuster who wasn't there. You're building a file, and the file is worth considerably more than any single photograph inside it.
Frequently asked
Do damaged window screens count as hail damage on a claim?
They're a covered item on most homeowners policies and they're worth listing. Their bigger value is evidential. Dished screens on one or two elevations establish the storm's direction and show the hail was large enough to do real work.
How do I see dents in aluminum trim wrap?
Look at it in raking light, early morning or late in the day, with your eye close to the plane of the surface. Direct midday sun hides shallow dents almost completely and makes damaged trim look untouched.
My siding is discontinued. Does the carrier have to replace all of it?
That depends on your state and your policy wording. Some Midwest states have matching rules and others don't, and carriers read similar language differently. Document the product and the discontinuation before you argue the point.
Can I file for the garage door and windows without the roof?
Yes, and sometimes that's the right call. If the roof inspects clean and the door and wraps are hit, that's a valid partial claim. We'd still want the roof documented so you have a dated baseline for next time.
Does damage to my air conditioner help the roof claim?
Flattened condenser fins are some of the best-dated evidence on the property. The fins are thin aluminum, they only bend one direction, and they sit at ground level where nobody can argue about access or interpretation.
Related reading
Free Hail Damage Inspection
No cost, no obligation, and you get the photographs either way.
Free inspection, documented for your claim.
One number reaches dispatch for all forty Midwest metros, answered live 24 hours a day.