
Midwest hail damage · Guards on the gutters
Gutter Guards After Midwest Hail Damage
The guards on your gutters took the same storm your roof did. Here's how to tell dented from dirty, and how they belong on the claim.
Short answer
Hail damages gutter guards the same way it damages gutters. Aluminum mesh and screen guards dent, bow inward or crack at their fasteners, and plastic guards can split. Document a damaged guard with dated photos and list it on the same claim as the roof and gutters, because the guard is part of the gutter system. If the gutters are being replaced, the guards have to come off anyway, so they're reinstalled or replaced in the same scope.
Reading the damage from a ladder
Micro-mesh guards are the easiest to read. The fine mesh sits in a frame, and each stone leaves a small round dimple where it landed. Run a gloved hand along the top and you'll feel them. On a perforated aluminum cover the dents are wider and shallower, and the light catches them if you sight down the run in late afternoon.
Plastic screens behave differently. They don't dent so much as fracture. Look for cracks fanning out from a screw, a snapped corner, or a section warped down into the trough. Foam inserts and brush guards almost never show hail at all, which is one of the few nice things about them.
Why a few dimples change how water moves
A dented guard still keeps leaves out. The problem is rain. Most guards depend on surface tension to pull water around a curved nose or down through a fine screen, and a dent in that curve sends water sheeting over the front lip instead. In a heavy July downpour, that's water landing beside the foundation, the exact spot you paid to protect.
Bowed guards trap debris too. After a hailstorm the gutters fill with shredded leaves and shingle granules, and a guard sagging into the trough holds that mix against the metal. Leave it a winter and you've built a dam that freezes solid at the eave, the start of the ice problems Midwest roofs know well.
Getting guards onto the claim
Adjusters walk a roof with a checklist, and guards slip through more often than you'd guess. The gutter gets a line item. The guard riding on it doesn't. So photograph them separately: a wide shot of each run, then close-ups with a coin or tape next to the dents. Note the brand and style if you know it, or lift one section and shoot the profile.
Dented guards also help the rest of the file. Soft metal is one of the things adjusters lean on to confirm that hail really struck the house, and a row of fresh dimples down every mesh panel is hard to dispute. We photograph them with the downspouts and vent caps for that reason. Our siding and gutter page covers the rest of the exterior.
Repair, reinstall or replace
Reinstall
Guards in good shape on gutters too dented to keep get pulled, set aside and put back on the new runs. That only works when the profile fits the new gutter.
Swap the guards only
Dimpled mesh over gutters that are still straight is common with smaller stones. The guards get replaced and the gutters stay.
Replace both
Bigger hail usually marks the gutter face and the guard together. Doing both at once keeps the fit right and avoids paying for a reinstall twice.
The catch with branded systems
Some guards are sold as a proprietary system, installed by one dealer, with their own hanger and a warranty tied to that installer. If that's what's on your house, the replacement price should reflect that product, not a generic screen from a home center. Dig the original invoice out of the drawer if you have it. It's the simplest proof of what was there.
The reverse happens as well. Someone with cheap snap-in screens hopes the claim will buy a premium micro-mesh system. It won't, and we won't write it up that way. The policy replaces damaged items with like kind and quality. If you want the upgrade, the difference is yours, and we'll show that figure on its own line so the claim stays clean.

Sequence on a full replacement
When the roof and gutters are both being replaced, order matters. Drip edge goes on, then shingles, then gutters are hung so the drip edge laps into them, and guards go last. Styles that tuck under the first shingle course go in best on a fresh roof. Jamming one under an old, sealed course tends to break the seal strip, and that's a wind problem waiting for the next storm.
A few honest limits
Guards don't stop ice dams. They don't make gutters maintenance-free, either, since seed pods and pine needles still sit on top of the mesh. And no metal guard comes through a serious hailstorm unmarked.
If your guards were old, loose or half-clogged before the storm, the claim won't treat them as new. Depreciation shows up on that line just as it does on the shingles, and some of it may come back once the work is finished.
One practical note. If the storm left the gutters packed with granules and leaf shreds, get them cleared before the next big rain, even if the claim isn't settled. Take your photos first, keep a bag of what you scooped out, and write the date on it. An overflowing gutter can rot a fascia board in a single wet season, and that's a repair no adjuster will tie back to the hail.

Questions homeowners ask us
Will insurance replace gutter guards damaged by hail?
Usually, when the damage is documented. Guards are part of the gutter system and fall under the same dwelling coverage. Photograph them separately so they don't get left off the estimate.
Can a guard be dented when the gutter isn't?
Yes. Thin mesh and perforated covers dent from smaller stones than a gutter face will, especially a heavy-gauge gutter run. The guard often shows the storm before anything else at the eave.
Are dented guards just cosmetic?
Sometimes. But a dent in the curved nose or a bow in the mesh changes how water enters the gutter, and if rain overshoots the front during a heavy storm, the damage is functional.
Should I pull my guards off to clean out hail debris?
Only if you're steady on a ladder and the guard is made to be removed. Photograph everything first. Taking a guard down before the adjuster sees it can make the damage harder to prove.
Do I have to use the same brand of guard?
The claim pays for like kind and quality, so a comparable guard is normally fine. If the original was a proprietary system, the replacement price should match it, and any upgrade beyond that is paid by the homeowner.
Keep reading on this site
Free Hail Damage Inspection
No cost, no obligation, and you get the photographs either way.
Free inspection, documented for your claim.
Call one number from any of our forty Midwest metros and a live dispatcher answers, day or night.