
Midwest hail damage · Warranties in plain English
Roof Warranties Explained for Midwest Hail Damage Roofs
Two warranties come with a new roof, and neither one covers hail. Here's what each actually promises and how to keep both in force.
Short answer
A new roof normally carries two separate warranties. The manufacturer's warranty covers defects in the shingles and other materials, and the contractor's workmanship warranty covers mistakes in how the roof was installed. Neither covers hail, wind beyond the shingle's rating or falling trees; storm damage is an insurance matter. John Beal Roofing includes a lifetime workmanship warranty on every roof it installs, alongside the manufacturer's standard product warranty.
The manufacturer's half
The shingle maker is warranting its product: that the shingle won't fail because of how it was made. Think granules washing off in sheets on a three-year-old roof, a batch that cracks across the tabs, sealant strips that never bond. Those are manufacturing problems, and they're rare.
The word to watch is limited. Most of these warranties open with a window of full coverage, after which any payout shrinks on a prorated schedule as the roof ages. Many cover material only, not the labor to tear off and reinstall. Terms differ by brand and product line, so read the written warranty for the exact shingle on your house rather than a brochure headline.
The contractor's half
Workmanship covers the installer. Nails driven too high so the shingle slides, flashing that wasn't stepped along a sidewall, a valley cut short, a pipe boot sealed with a tube of caulk instead of the right part. Those mistakes show up as leaks, usually in the first few years, and none of them are the shingle's fault.
This is the warranty that depends most on who you hire. A workmanship promise from a crew that won't exist in five years is a piece of paper. Our family has been roofing for three generations, since 1947, and every roof we install carries a lifetime workmanship warranty. It's standard. It isn't a tier you pay extra to reach.
Why hail sits outside both
Hail is an outside event. The shingle didn't fail from a defect and the installer didn't make an error; a stone fractured the mat. Paying for that is your homeowner's policy's job, and the claim process is a separate track from any warranty.
Impact-rated shingles don't change that. A Class 4 label means the product passed the UL 2218 steel-ball drop test. It's a test result, not a guarantee against every storm. Many carriers give a premium credit for Class 4 shingles, and that's a different benefit from anything in the warranty booklet.
Ways homeowners void coverage without realizing it
A hot attic
Shingle makers write ventilation requirements into their installation instructions. An attic that bakes the deck all summer can cost you coverage on premature aging. We cover the fix on our ventilation page.
Pressure washing
Blasting moss or streaks off with a pressure washer strips granules. That's damage no manufacturer will pay for.
Mismatched components
Some warranties apply only when starter, ridge cap and underlayment come from the same maker. Ask before anyone patches with whatever's on the truck.
Someone else's repair
If another contractor cuts into the roof and a leak follows, the original workmanship coverage generally won't extend to that work. Call your installer first.
What we won't sell you
Shingle makers market upgraded system warranties that a certified contractor can register for an added fee. We don't offer those. Every roof gets the same lifetime workmanship warranty from us plus the manufacturer's standard product warranty, and we'd rather say so plainly than upsell a certificate.
We hold Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, GAF Master Elite and CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster status, meaning those manufacturers have vetted how we install. It doesn't change our position on paid upgrades.

Paperwork to keep in one folder
File the signed contract, the final invoice, the shingle product name and color, and the workmanship warranty document together. If the manufacturer requires registration, keep the confirmation. When you sell, that folder is the first thing a buyer's inspector asks about, and manufacturer transfer rules often carry a deadline after closing.
When a roof we installed takes hail
The workmanship warranty doesn't pay for storm damage, and neither does the shingle maker. You file a claim like anyone else. What changes is the inspection. We already know how that roof went on, so separating a fresh strike from an installation issue is quick, and we can document it for your adjuster without guesswork.
If you're shopping for a replacement right now, ask every bidder to put their workmanship terms in writing before you sign, and compare them line by line alongside the price. A bid that's cheaper by a few hundred dollars and backed by a one-year promise isn't actually cheaper.
Four things to get in writing
Who issues each warranty
The shingle maker issues one, the contractor issues the other. Each should be its own document with its own name at the top, not a paragraph buried in a sales brochure.
What's excluded
Every warranty has an exclusions list. Storms, foundation settling, owner modifications and lack of maintenance show up on most of them. Read that list before you read the promises.
Labor or material
Find out whether a valid manufacturer claim pays for new shingles only, or for the crew to install them too. That single line decides what a claim is worth years from now.
How to file a claim
A phone number and an address that still work when you need them. Write them on the folder itself.

Questions homeowners ask us
Does a roof warranty cover hail damage?
No. Manufacturer warranties cover material defects and workmanship warranties cover installation errors. Hail is covered, if at all, by your homeowner's insurance policy.
What does a lifetime workmanship warranty mean?
The installer stands behind the installation itself, covering leaks and failures caused by how the roof was put on. At John Beal Roofing it comes standard on every roof we install rather than as a paid add-on.
Is a shingle warranty transferable when I sell my home?
Many are, often once and within a set window after the sale, sometimes with a registration step. Terms vary by product line, so read the warranty for your specific shingle.
Can another roofer's repair void my warranty?
It can. If a different contractor works on the roof and a problem traces back to that work, the original installer's workmanship coverage generally won't extend to it. Call your installer first.
Do Class 4 shingles come with a hail guarantee?
The impact rating is a laboratory result, not a promise that hail won't damage the roof. The financial benefit is usually an insurance premium credit, and that varies by carrier.
Keep reading on this site
Free Hail Damage Inspection
No cost, no obligation, and you get the photographs either way.
Free inspection, documented for your claim.
Call one number from any of our forty Midwest metros and a live dispatcher answers, day or night.